This episode of Justice for All with Judge Cristina Perez features a legal dispute between a former live-in nanny, Josie Way (Plaintiff), and her former employer, Tracy Yang (Defendant)
-
The Lawsuit: Josie sued Tracy for $3,200 in unpaid wages for her final month of nanny services
-
The Termination: Tracy fired Josie abruptly at the end of the month after Josie confessed that she had been having a year-long affair with Tracy’s husband, Steven.
-
Crucial Context: Steven had recently died of a heart attack . Josie chose to confess the affair—and reveal that she was 6 months pregnant with Steven’s child—to Tracy on the exact day of Steven’s burial.
Key Arguments & Legal Issues
-
Breach of Contract vs. Unpaid Wages:
-
Josie’s Argument: She completed her regular duties (childcare, cooking, cleaning) for the full month and maintained that under the employment contract, she was legally owed payment.
-
Tracy’s Argument: The employment contract explicitly required professional behavior. Sleeping with her employer’s husband in the family home constituted a direct breach of contract and gross misconduct, nullifying payment.
-
-
Ethical Considerations & Paternity:
-
Judge Perez strongly criticized Josie’s lack of professional ethics and empathy, particularly for revealing the secret on the day of the husband’s funeral.
-
Tracy initially questioned whether the unborn baby was actually Steven’s due to Josie’s past dating history. Both parties agreed to reveal court-ordered paternity results during the trial.
-
The Verdict & Outcome
-
Ruling on Wages: Judge Perez ruled in favor of the defendant (Tracy) and denied Josie’s claim for $3,200. The judge determined that engaging in a year-long affair with her employer’s husband violated the standard of professional behavior required by the nanny contract.
-
Paternity Test Results: The paternity test was revealed in court, officially confirming that the unborn child is Steven’s.
-
Legal Next Steps: Judge Perez advised Josie that since Steven is deceased, any future claims for child support must be filed against Steven’s legal estate .
